BFD, it still far too expensive to run and maintain and $$$/yr. basis.
insurance
fuel (does the Honda use premium?)
exhorbitant Honda dealer maintenance costs
MSRP +
never good financing rates
i don't care if their percentage is higher.
Your average Odyssey is about 7-10 grand more across the board than the equal Caravan in real world pricing.
You don't make that up at trade in time.
A very well equipped Grand Caravan SXT that lists for 28 will sell for 21.
If the Caravan holds to even 46% of MSRP after 3 year that = 12880. 21,000-12,880 = 8120.
If the equivalently equipped Odyssey is priced out its at 30,000, and that's what the morons pay for it. To be kind, I will say 29,000. If we say it holds 54% after 3 years (which is being generous) that's 30,000 x .54 = 16,200. 29,000-16,200= 12,800 plus even more on sales taxes, insurance and maintenance.
So even if you think they can justify your yuppie/Honda desire by saying its financially sound to get the Honda, its not. Even in the first years, even facotirng better resale percentages, the Honda still is too much money.
Those parents ought to be ashamed to dump all that extra money on the Honda when it could go into their kids college fund or their own 401k's.....
To top it off, well maintained minivans of any brand will hold their value as well as any other. If you have an excellent mininvan with good miles that not hashed and w/ maintennace records you can unload it in just a couple days and goet near full retail value for it. It that case the Dodge will save you even more money.
No one buys Honda for value. You buy one to stroke your own yuppie stir-fry ego.