Motor Trend's BDC Extension Test- M2, FoRS, More

[Frisky Dingo]

The Link

 

Check and and see what you guys think.

[G. David Felt]

I read this story earlier and actually think it was spot on from my own experience with some of the auto's. The only big thing I disagreed with was the First place winner should have been last place. But that is just me. Loved the rebuttals.

[ccap41]

55 minutes ago, dfelt said:

I read this story earlier and actually think it was spot on from my own experience with some of the auto's. The only big thing I disagreed with was the First place winner should have been last place. But that is just me. Loved the rebuttals.

I thought the same. How in the world did the 'worse Miata' beat that crowd in best driver's car?

[Frisky Dingo]

I highly questioned the finishing order. Some of the things they used as reasoning for one car finishing further down were things they held against a car higher up. Take the Boxster vs the Fiat, for instance. If the cars have the same cons, but one offers vastly more performance and capability, why would it finish worse?

The Porsche should have won this all day long. Fiat should have been mid-pack at best.

[daves87rs]

Kinda an odd order.....judging by what I read-maybe there should not be an order......

[Frisky Dingo]

12 hours ago, daves87rs said:

Kinda an odd order.....judging by what I read-maybe there should not be an order......

Yeah, I agree. Very wishy-washy.