Jump to content
Create New...

Recommended Posts

Posted

http://www6.autonet.ca/News/story.cfm?stor...3769969-cp.html

  Quote

TORONTO (CP) - BMW has prevailed over Infiniti in a court battle over the letter M.

The ruling by Federal Court Justice W. Andrew MacKay found that the use of the letter by Infiniti, the premium brand of Japanese carmaker Nissan, "in form similar to that of the plaintiffs' trademark M alone, and its use of M6 as a package for modifying one of its vehicles, cause confusion in Canada between the sources of the wares of the defendant and the wares of the plaintiffs."

BMW has been adding M badges to souped-up versions of its already high-performance cars since 1978 in Germany and 1987 in Canada, when the M6 arrived, followed by the M3, the M5 and other variants.

The German carmaker argued that these vehicles have come to be known, "particularly by auto journalists and car enthusiasts," as M cars which enhance the image and sales of the rest of its fleet.

Infiniti, meanwhile, registered M45 in 2004 and M35 in 2005 as trademarks for sedans in the middle of its range, and in some advertising has used the letter M alone. It also offered an M6 sport package for its lower-priced G35.

The judge found Nissan "liable, in damages to be determined . . . for the use of the letter M and the descriptor M6, as trademarks for automobiles, parts and accessories, which caused a likelihood of confusion between the sources of its wares and of BMW's."

Nissan was barred from directing public attention to its products in any way likely to cause confusion.

"The defendant is also ordered to deliver to the plaintiffs or to destroy under oath, all literature, invoices, packaging, signs, advertisements, promotional or marketing material, printed or otherwise recorded, in the possession, custody or control of the defendant which may be considered to offend the injunction now granted."

Submissions will be considered later on monetary damages and legal costs.

Posted
  balthazar said:

Tho for the life of me I've never encountered the term 'M-car' in reference to the bmws, the ruling makes sense, esp when compounded by useage of 'M-car' and M6 by nissan. Dopes.

Huh? You've never heard of the M3, M5, or M6?

Posted

This is stupid for several reasons:

1. "M6" is not the name of a G35 sport package. It refers to the 6-speed manual transmission you can get with the G35 Sport. I'm pretty sure Nissan isn't the only one that uses "M6" is that respect. They don't use the term "M6" in any sort of promotion or advertising.

2. What about Nissan's "Z" that way predates the BMW "Z"?

3. On the USPTO web site, whenever there a filing of an alphanumeric trademark there is a disclaimer that clearly states something along the lines of that you can't lay claim to a letter itself, only a far as the letter/number combination that's being filed.

In short, this lawsuit (and the ruling) was retarded.

Posted
  Variance said:

2. What about Nissan's "Z" that way predates the BMW "Z"?

Well, not necessarily...The alphanumerics are in different orders...like 280Z or 350Z...BMW uses it like Z4 or Z3 (etc....), and they call the M-versions of those models "m-coupe" or "m-roadster".

It's a silly lawsuit to an extent because I don't think many people get the two confused, though I have heard the term "m-cars" used in reference to BMW's. It is pushing it just a bit.

Posted (edited)

So apparently you can patent letters in Canada.

And only BMW may use 6-speed manuals in Canada.

What a big win for BMW in Canada!

Either that or the judge never heard of transmissions, and this ruling will get immediately overturned.

Or the judge recently just began driving a brand new BMW M6.

Ironically, the BMW M6 is a 7 speed SMG, while everyone else's M6 is a 6 speed manual.

Edited by JT64
Posted (edited)
  Variance said:

This is stupid for several reasons:

1. "M6" is not the name of a G35 sport package. It refers to the 6-speed manual transmission you can get with the G35 Sport. I'm pretty sure Nissan isn't the only one that uses "M6" is that respect. They don't use the term "M6" in any sort of promotion or advertising.

2. What about Nissan's "Z" that way predates the BMW "Z"?

3. On the USPTO web site, whenever there a filing of an alphanumeric trademark there is a disclaimer that clearly states something along the lines of that you can't lay claim to a letter itself, only a far as the letter/number combination that's being filed.

In short, this lawsuit (and the ruling) was retarded.

:withstupid: Edited by blackviper8891
Posted

Hmmm...something about this seems familiar. Oh yeah here it is from March 24, 2005.

http://www.igorinternational.com/press/det...ming-expert.php

A snippet:

  Quote

Nissan North America Inc. -- which already has the Z, a cool sports car and what may be the coolest letter in the alphabet -- sued Audi of America Inc. Tuesday in a Michigan federal court over its planned use of the letter Q as a prefix to name a few new SUVs.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...

Hey there, we noticed you're using an ad-blocker. We're a small site that is supported by ads or subscriptions. We rely on these to pay for server costs and vehicle reviews.  Please consider whitelisting us in your ad-blocker, or if you really like what you see, you can pick up one of our subscriptions for just $1.75 a month or $15 a year. It may not seem like a lot, but it goes a long way to help support real, honest content, that isn't generated by an AI bot.

See you out there.

Drew
Editor-in-Chief

This Topic

Write what you are looking for and press enter or click the search icon to begin your search