GM Sued Over Inaccurate Speedometers

[Cory Wolfe]

Suits filed over GM speedometers

By David Bowermaster

Seattle Times staff reporter

Kevin Zwicker knew something was wrong when the speedometer on his 2004 Chevy Suburban indicated he was going 10 mph, even though he was driving at or near the speed limit on Interstate 5.

Zwicker's speedometer failed completely in April 2006. But General Motors did not replace it for free because the truck was outside the standard three-year, 36,000-mile warranty period.

Zwicker had purchased an extended warranty, so he paid $100 for a new speedometer rather than the usual $400 to $500.

But now Zwicker, who lives in Snohomish, is the lead plaintiff in a federal lawsuit seeking damages on behalf of potentially thousands of people. The lawsuit, filed last week in U.S. District Court in Seattle, could potentially cover all Washington residents who purchased GM trucks and sport-utility vehicles from 2003 to 2007, and who have had to replace defective speedometers.

Zwicker, 48, considers himself a "savvy driver," but said it was uncomfortable driving without knowing how fast he was going.

"I don't think it's fair that a major manufacturer such as GM can let something like this go by and not give it some serious thought," Zwicker said.

A nearly identical suit was filed this week in U.S. District Court in Oregon on behalf of John Hall, who paid $427.50 in January to fix a defective speedometer on his 2003 GMC Envoy LE.

The lawsuits in Washington and Oregon are seeking class-action status, according to Beth Terrell, an attorney with the Seattle law firm of Tousley Brain Stephens who is representing Hall and Zwicker. The suits cover five Chevrolet models: Avalanche, Silverado, Suburban, Tahoe and Trailblazer; four GMC models: Denali, Envoy, Sierra and Trailblazer; and the Cadillac Escalade.

Additional suits could follow in other states, but there are currently no plans to consolidate the cases into a single national suit against the world's largest automaker.

"We think it makes sense to prosecute GM in each state on behalf of that state's residents," Terrell said.

More: Clicky

[Drew Dowdell]

things break.... get over it.

[siegen]

Well the speedometer is one of the few things that hasn't broke on our '04 Sierra. So I'll just keep my fingers crossed.

[corvette_dude729]

This happened on my sister's Grand Am also. It wasn;t the speedometer but something else electrical associated with the whole I/P. Her fuel readings were wrong too.

[Flybrian]

This, like Honda's odometer lawsuit, is ridiculous.

My car's cupholder broke. I feel uncomfortable travelling without hydration. Sue GM.

[BlkHhr104]

Oh my God stop cryinggg... this happened on my mothers TrailBlazer... she pulled over restarted the car... good as new.. is that so hard Mr. Zwicker

[Intrepidation]

One of the light bulbs burned out on the tachometer of the Intrepid....Sue for it faulty light bulbs! (because since when do light bulbs burn out and since when does anything break?!)

Edited March 5, 2007 by Dodgefan

[siegen]

This, like Honda's odometer lawsuit, is ridiculous.

My car's cupholder broke. I feel uncomfortable travelling without hydration. Sue GM.

I would consider a speedometer failing important. GM should issue a recall if there are enough people with faulty speedometers, otherwise they will just get sued like they are now. The thread title is misleading, the speedometers aren't inaccurate by a few %, they fail, or read considerably wrong.

[ellives]

I would consider a speedometer failing important. GM should issue a recall if there are enough people with faulty speedometers, otherwise they will just get sued like they are now. The thread title is misleading, the speedometers aren't inaccurate by a few %, they fail, or read considerably wrong.

What's "enough" people? I saw two people referenced in the article and they're both probably dirtbag lawyers.

[FAPTurbo]

This, like Honda's odometer lawsuit, is ridiculous.

[siegen]

What's "enough" people? I saw two people referenced in the article and they're both probably dirtbag lawyers.

I don't know how many it takes before they will do a recall. Maybe the two people are isolated cases and just sewing cause they're poor. =)

[FAPTurbo]

I don't know how many it takes before they will do a recall. Maybe the two people are isolated cases and just sewing cause they're poor. =)

Welcome to North America.

[Northstar]

I would consider a speedometer failing important. GM should issue a recall if there are enough people with faulty speedometers, otherwise they will just get sued like they are now. The thread title is misleading, the speedometers aren't inaccurate by a few %, they fail, or read considerably wrong.

I would consider a transmission, engine, or brake system failing important as well. That doesn't mean that you get to sue the automaker because your engine failed outside of warranty. The speedo is the same way.

Unless there are a large number of speedometers, there is no reason to issue a recall, and no reason to be sued. Things break, people can't expect everything to work perfectly forever.

[Z-06]

Tomorrow, I am gonna sue GOD for making me only 5'10" tall instead of 6' and I have a class action pending with other people sharing my grief.

[ocnblu]

I'm signing up for that one, but I want more compensation because I only reached 5'5".

[ellives]

Tomorrow, I am gonna sue GOD for making me only 5'10" tall instead of 6' and I have a class action pending with other people sharing my grief.

Let us know if that works for ya. I'm sure we can all come up with deficiencies we'd like to sue for.

[Oracle of Delphi]

You should only sue God if he gave you a short penis, otherwise be thankful!

Thank you God!

[ocnblu]

Rink prease.

[Oracle of Delphi]

Are you following me?

[ocnblu]

Nah, I live here. Just joshing with you, sir.

[Oracle of Delphi]

It's kool dude, no worries!

[ocnblu]

Alrighty then, compadre.

[-Camaro-]

Buying parts from a dealership is like flushing your money down the toilet... I mean $400-500 for a speedometer?! Give me a break! It's only worth at the most $100.

[Cory Wolfe]

This, like Honda's odometer lawsuit, is ridiculous.

My car's cupholder broke. I feel uncomfortable travelling without hydration. Sue GM.

As far as the thread title, I originally saw this on Autoblog and that was the title.

[balthazar]

Feel free to correct a misleading title, BV; consider it a public service.

[sciguy_0504]

It's one thing if this is a widespread problem. It's another when it happens twice and people are just looking to make an easy buck.

[scharmer05]

Happened in my dad's 04 Silverado before he got rid of it. Was very inaccurate for a couple of months, then fell off to zero. Instead of letting me buy one for him off of ebay, he decided to just drive with the Tach for a couple more months until he traded it off.

[Polish_Kris]

This, like Honda's odometer lawsuit, is ridiculous.

My car's cupholder broke. I feel uncomfortable travelling without hydration. Sue GM.

I heard down in the states they sue the weatherman for predicting the wrong weather

[ellives]

I heard down in the states they sue the weatherman for predicting the wrong weather

:AH-HA_wink: If only we could. The problem would be there wouldn't BE any weathermen because they'd all get sued.

[zhawk]

I heard down in the states they sue the weatherman for predicting the wrong weather

If only.

I must be nice to be able to be wrong at least 50% of the time and still have job security.

Actually, here in Washington State the weatherman xould just call for rain everyday and if it doesn't then tell people to be happy about getting sun. lol

[SS427]

:AH-HA_wink: If only we could. The problem would be there wouldn't BE any weathermen because they'd all get sued.

I wonder if that would work with lawyers? Edited March 24, 2007 by SS427

[ellives]

I wonder if that would work with lawyers?

I'm sure they'd figure out a way to screw somebody, somehow. That's what they do for a living isn't it?

[Paolino]

Tomorrow, I am gonna sue GOD for making me only 5'10" tall instead of 6' and I have a class action pending with other people sharing my grief.

I'm signing up for that one, but I want more compensation because I only reached 5'5".

Listen, you're not missing much... the air isn't any cleaner, the earlier warning for rain isn't significant enough to make a difference, and you have a higher rate of banging your head on things.

:AH-HA_wink:

[RBB]

I must be nice to be able to be wrong at least 50% of the time and still have job security.

Wait, are you talking about meterologists or Ford CEOs?

-RBB

[ellives]

Wait, are you talking about meterologists or Ford CEOs?

-RBB

Hmmm - me thinks Ford CEO's haven't been right even 50 percent of the time lately. Maybe others disagree.

Edited March 26, 2007 by ellives

[Drew Dowdell]

I'm signing up for that one, but I want more compensation because I only reached 5'5".

quiet shorty!

[Dragon]

Wait, are you talking about meterologists or Ford CEOs?

-RBB

right 50%? damn those are some good meteorologists

[the_yellow_dart]

quiet shorty!

I'm proud of him. He can reach the keyboard! :AH-HA_wink:

[76ChevyTrucker]

You know, I heard of a similar problem once before with a friend of a friend's Silverado. It had the speed-to-volume proportional stereo and a component went bad in the radio, which caused the speedometer to konk out. Because apparently the input signal from the Vehice Speed Sensor (VSS), comes through the radio first, then goes to the IP.

[Mr.Krinkle]

Whats up with that radio? Isnt the trans tied into there that way somehow?